Not That Jewish

By Monica Piper; Directed by Mark Waldrop
Produced by Jewish Women's Theatre

Off Broadway, Solo Show
On sale through 9.3.17
New World Stages, 340 West 50th Street


by Lexi Orphanos on 3.27.17


Not That JewishMonica Piper in Not That Jewish. Photo by Carol Rosegg.

BOTTOM LINE: Through a series of schtick-filled parlor stories, Monica Piper exemplifies with great heart what it really means to be Jew"ish."

Monica Piper grew up as a Jewish girl in the Bronx knowing no Hebrew and belonging to no temple. Her family always knew, though, that being Jewish was something that's in your heart. But even more dominant in their hearts was a love of comedy. They would dress up and stand on the doorstep, tossing out small talk like "excellent service today," creating the facade of having just gone to temple. The family performed in greater acts than simple doorstep tableaus, though. Piper's father, Roy Davis (born David Poss), was a variety show hit as a "vocal pantomimer" and played packed houses nationwide, showing off his chops. When Piper was born, as she explains in the show, her father always told her, "kid, you're funny," and with his blessing, she knew she was destined to be exactly that.

As Piper sits in her faux living room onstage, she tells her life story of how Jew"ish" May Lee Davis became award-winning artist Monica Piper, and despite changing her name, found her true self along the way. From divorce to The Comedy Store, the loss of a parent to the adoption of her son, winning an Emmy to her breast cancer recovery, Piper delivers an intimate performance within the large proscenium at New World Stages. Through all the teary moments in the audience, Piper manages to bring a smile back with one of her jokes and expert physical comedy. In some moments, it is easy to eagerly await the next punchline, like watching a standup comic's routine, while in others, Piper captures true theatre and creates a tangible stillness in the crowd as she, herself, struggles to find the right words. Thematically, Piper returns again and again to the notion that humor is essential to being Jewish: "we have a way of making dark times okay," she says. Not That Jewish shows that so long as you have compassion, strength, and the ability to add "sh" to the beginning of a word, then you're Jewish enough. But don't worry—the program comes complete with Piper's own "Yiddish 101" pamphlet.

(Not That Jewish plays at New World Stages, 340 West 50th Street. Tickets are on sale through September 3, 2017. The running time is 90 minutes with no intermission. Performances are Mondays at 7; Thursdays at 2 and 7; Fridays at 8; Saturdays at 2 and 8; and Sundays at 3. Tickets are $49 - $85 and are available at or by calling 212-239-6200. For more information visit


Not That Jewish is written and performed by Monica Piper. Directed by Mark Waldrop. Scenic Design by Michael Carnahan. Projection Design by Zachary Borovay. Sound Design by Ian Wehrle. Lighting Design by Julie Duro. Stage Management by Katrina Olson. Produced by Michael Alden, Ronda Spinak, Alan Duncan Ross, Marcia Seligson, Jim Russek, Richard Winkler, the Leighton Family Trust, and Jamie deRoy in association with Jewish Women's Theatre.