One Christmas Eve

By Lynne Halliday, James Hindman, Arlene Hutton, and Craig Pospisil; Directed by Chris Goutman
Produced by Schondeikkan Productions in association with The Journey Company
Part of the 2018 New York International Fringe Festival

Off Off Broadway, Short Plays
Runs through 10.24.18
FringeHUB, 685 Washington Street


by Charlotte Arnoux on 10.27.18


One Christmas EveAdrienne Paquin and James Taylor Odom in One Christmas Eve. Photo by Braden Wilkerson.


BOTTOM LINE: A look into the crisscrossing lives of shoppers at a Midwestern mall on Christmas Eve.

From the team that brought us one of 2016 Fringe’s most celebrated plays—The Gorges Motel—comes a new piece: One Christmas Eve. The play welcomes the audience into intertwined stories of shoppers at a Michigan mall on Christmas Eve. The piece is structured as a series of nine short plays, performed with sleek and smooth transitions, imagined by director Chris Goutman. Each piece stands well on its own and varies in genre and subject matter, though the playwrights take advantage of the high stakes of the holidays. Christmastime can be, as the various playwrights explore, the “most wonderful time of the year,” but also the most stressful, painful, nostalgic, fraught, and silly.

Throughout the program, the artists of One Christmas Eve drop us into slivers of lives of various characters throughout the mall. There are the characters who are just home for the holidays: the daughter home from college for the first time since her parents’ divorce, and the high school couple reunited for one last “what if.” Others are deep in the business of Christmas: the disgruntled mall actor, stuck in the role of Marley in A Christmas Carol; the underpaid and overworked athletic store saleswoman who is frustrated she didn’t get the promotion she deserved; the overeager mall cop, too quick to call 9-11; and the Santa-and-elf duo, who are just in it for the cheer. And then there are characters who grapple with the pressures of tradition: the struggling mother forced to shoplift for her daughter’s gift, and the widower and his new wife, reckoning with old family traditions.

Weaving these stories together is the spirited cast of One Christmas Eve. Standout actors include the versatile and commanding Darcie Siciliano, and the beguiling and spry James Taylor Odom. The plays that veer most out of traditional story lines and take full advantage of the talented cast are James Hindman’s Good Will Toward Men and Craig Pospisil’s Bearing Gifts We Traverse Afar.

One Christmas Eve is a charming and mostly predictable evening of plays. It’s wrapped up with a pretty song like a ribbon wraps a gift. The song, directed at the audience, wishes us all a Merry Christmas. It’s nice, but a little strange in mid-October.

(One Christmas Eve plays at FringeHUB, 685 Washington Street at Charles Street, through October 24, 2018. Meet at the DARK GREEN FringeNYC flag. The running time is 1 hour 20 minutes. Performances are Fri 10/12 at 7, Sun 10/14 at 7:30, Sat 10/20 at 7:15, and Wed 10/24 at 7. There is no late seating at FringeNYC. Tickets are $22 (plus $3.69 ticketing fee), $16 (plus $3.51) for seniors, and are ONLY available online at For more information visit

One Christmas Eve is by Lynne Halliday, James Hindman, Arlene Hutton, and Craig Pospisil. Directed by Chris Goutman. Set Design and Lighting by Eric Nightengale. Costume Design by Jane Parson. Stage Manager is Christina Schmidt. Produced by Schondeikkan Productions.

The cast is Alexandra Bonesho, James Taylor Odom, Leighton Samuels, Aaron D. McMillan, Adrienne Paquin, and Darcie Siciliano.